14. Success Criteria¶
14.1. Technical Metrics¶
14.1.1. Search Performance¶
Metric |
Target |
Measurement Method |
|---|---|---|
Vector search latency (p95) |
<100ms |
Elasticsearch slow log analysis |
kNN recall@10 |
>85% |
Evaluation on curated test set |
Text search latency (p95) |
<50ms |
Elasticsearch slow log analysis |
Completion suggest latency (p95) |
<20ms |
Elasticsearch slow log analysis |
Query error rate |
<0.1% |
Application error logging |
14.1.2. Index Quality¶
Metric |
Target |
Measurement Method |
|---|---|---|
Embedding coverage |
>99% of toponyms |
Field existence query |
Cross-reference coverage |
>50% of places |
Relations field analysis |
Duplicate rate |
<1% |
Clustering analysis |
14.1.3. Training Data Quality¶
Metric |
Target |
Measurement Method |
|---|---|---|
Training candidate coverage |
>50% of languages |
Language distribution analysis |
Cluster purity |
>90% |
Manual spot-check of sample clusters |
Triplet validity |
>95% |
Validation against known equivalents |
14.1.4. Operational¶
Metric |
Target |
Measurement Method |
|---|---|---|
Index uptime |
>99.9% |
Cluster health monitoring |
Snapshot success rate |
100% |
Snapshot status API |
Reindex duration |
<24 hours |
Job timing logs |
Recovery time objective |
<1 hour |
Restore drill timing |
14.2. User Experience Metrics¶
14.2.1. Search Quality¶
Metric |
Target |
Measurement Method |
|---|---|---|
Relevant results in top 10 |
>80% |
User evaluation study |
Cross-lingual match success |
>70% |
Curated test queries |
Historical variant match |
>60% |
Curated test queries |
Typo tolerance |
>90% for 1-2 char errors |
Synthetic typo test set |
14.2.2. User Satisfaction¶
Metric |
Target |
Measurement Method |
|---|---|---|
Search success rate |
>90% |
“No results” rate reduction |
Click-through rate |
Improvement vs baseline |
Analytics tracking |
User feedback score |
>4/5 |
Survey responses |
14.3. Research Impact¶
14.3.1. Data Contribution¶
Deliverable |
Target |
|---|---|
Trained Siamese BiLSTM model |
Open-source release |
Training data (triplets) |
Publicly available |
Processing pipeline |
Documented and reproducible |
Evaluation test set |
Published for benchmarking |
14.3.2. Scholarly Output¶
Deliverable |
Target |
|---|---|
Methodology paper |
Peer-reviewed publication |
Technical documentation |
Comprehensive and maintained |
Workshop/tutorial |
Conference presentation |
14.4. Acceptance Criteria by Phase¶
14.4.1. Phase 2: Core Index Population¶
All authority sources ingested
Document counts match expectations (±1%)
Sample queries return expected results
Snapshot created and verified
14.4.2. Phase 4: Embedding Generation¶
BiLSTM model achieves recall@10 >80% on validation set
All toponyms have embeddings
kNN search returns results in <100ms (p95)
Vector search quality exceeds text-only baseline
14.4.3. Phase 6: Production Rollout¶
All technical metrics meet targets
User evaluation scores >4/5
Documentation complete
Runbooks tested and verified